Breaking Up Is Hard to Do
By Julie Nisbet
It might come as a surprise to some to learn that although I am a self-admitted TV Slut, I haven’t had many long-term relationships with TV shows. But then again, I’m a TV Slut, not a TV Serial Monogamist. It’s a big deal for me to commit to watching a show at the same time every week, and it’s hard not to be bitter when those relationships end badly.
Some of my TV break-ups were just sad, abrupt and unexplained: Arrested Development, My So Called Life, how I miss you so. But with others, something just changed. My shows became something I didn’t recognize anymore. Those are the hardest to let go. When do you throw in the towel and admit to yourself that the characters and plot lines you fell in love with aren’t the same anymore?
In no particular order, and in true Nick Hornby style, here are the top 3 all-time worst break-ups of my TV watching career.
3. Saved by the Bell
Some would argue that this was never a “good” show, but I LOVED it. I still sport a Bayside Tigers T-shirt that my sister bought for me, and I still love Zach Morris, but sometimes, I just have to wonder, “What happened?” I tried to stick with it. I suffered through the Tori years, telling myself that the Zach/Tori love affair could somehow compare to the Zach/Kelly years. But then came The College Years, The New Class, The New Class with Screech and Mr. Belding… Eventually, I couldn’t take it anymore, so I broke it off. Thankfully, I can still relive the glory years by watching reruns on TBS and the beauty that is DVD box sets: Hot Sundae, dance-offs at The Max, Jesse’s father’s wedding in Palm Springs and using fake IDs to get into The Attic. Hot.
2. Dawson’s Creek
Maybe it was because when this show started, I was a sophomore in high school, as were Dawson, Joey, Pacey and Jen. Maybe it was because my friends and I were obsessed with Joshua “warm ears” Jackson ever since having a Mighty Ducks marathon at my house several years prior. For whatever reason, I fell in love with Dawson’s before the pilot even aired. We had a good run. I loved this show solidly for 3.5 seasons, tuning in every Wednesday at 9pm. But then, suddenly, and with only a few episodes left in Season 4, Pacey and Joey broke up. With that breakup went the chemistry that was keeping the show together, and everything started falling apart. Suddenly, every male character ever introduced to the show fell in love with Joey. Then they introduced Audrey, Joey’s obnoxious roommate, who became Pacey’s love interest?! Like he would stoop SO low. Then, the writers started ripping off story lines from sub-par Giovanni Ribisi movies, and with that came the dreaded Pacey goatee. All I can say is that I’m glad I got out when I did and I don’t know why they even bothered making DVD box sets of the final 2 seasons.
1. Lost
I’m still casually dating Lost. It has a place on my Tivo and I check in every now and then, but the passion is gone. I very much would like the writers to pull it out of the downward spiral it’s been in since the beginning of season 2, but it’s not looking good. I could go on for pages about how I feel about the writers being slaves to formats, introducing new characters when we already can’t keep track of the ones we have, boring storylines, and so many loose ends that I can’t even keep track of them, but instead, all I will say is, “It’s not you, it’s me.”